Custom Cakes & Catering
Beyond the monthly drop, Sweetery 27 takes a limited number of custom cake and catering orders — for weddings, birthdays, corporate events, and anything worth celebrating.
How custom orders work
Fill out the inquiry form with your event details, items you want, and any notes.
If a slot is available, we'll confirm and send a quote within 2–3 business days.
A deposit secures your slot. Your order isn't locked in until payment is received.
Pick up at our Madison location on your agreed date and time.
Catering menu
Browse what's available and tell us what you'd like in the inquiry form.
Not sure what you need? Just tell us about your event, your guest count, and any items you're drawn to. We'll help figure out the rest and send a custom quote.
Custom cake formats
All custom cakes feature a clean, smooth buttercream finish.
6" & 8" Cakes
Our signature formats. Perfect for intimate gatherings of all sizes.
Starting at $48
10" Cake & Half Sheet
The 10" serves 20–25; the half sheet serves up to 54.
Starting at $85
Tiered Cake
Two, three, or four tiers. Each tier can be a different flavor.
Inquire for pricing
The Signature Collection
Each cake is named after a woman who embodies its spirit — bold, layered, and unforgettable.
"The Visionary"
Alina
Vanilla cake · Triple berry compote · Chantilly cream · Fresh berries
"The Joyful One"
Phoenix
Funfetti vanilla cake · Cheesecake filling
"The Zesty One"
Shiloh
Lemon cake · Lemon curd · Lemon buttercream
"The Bold Beauty"
Nyla
Black velvet cake · Ganache · Raspberry Swiss meringue buttercream
"The Catalyst"
Qwantese
Chocolate cake · Ganache · Peanut butter mousse · PB cup pieces
"The Rare Gem"
Kiana
Chocolate cake · Banana filling · Cream cheese buttercream · Fresh banana slices
"The Comforter"
Danielle
Apple spice cake · Brown butter cream cheese buttercream · Salted caramel drizzle
"The Gentle Heart"
Bria
Red velvet cake · Whipped cream cheese buttercream
"The Trailblazer"
Jamie
Carrot cake · Brown butter cream cheese buttercream
"The Powerhouse"
Tierra
Strawberry cake · Cheesecake filling · Graham cracker crumble · Strawberry compote · Dual buttercream
"The Prayerful Heart"
Kevi
Brown sugar cake · Biscoff cookie butter filling · Biscoff buttercream · Biscoff cookie crumbs
"The Prophetess"
Tai
Chai-spiced cake · Pear filling · Cream cheese buttercream
"The Visionary"
Vanilla cake, triple berry compote, chantilly cream, fresh berries.
Bold yet refined — timeless elegance with a vibrant burst of flavor.
"The Joyful One"
Funfetti vanilla cake, cheesecake filling.
Playful, musical, and bursting with happiness.
"The Zesty One"
Lemon cake, lemon curd, lemon buttercream.
Bright, tangy, and full of personality.
"The Bold Beauty"
Black velvet cake, ganache filling, raspberry Swiss meringue buttercream.
Rich, elegant, and strikingly radiant.
"The Catalyst"
Chocolate cake, ganache, peanut butter mousse, PB cup pieces.
Playful, magnetic, and full of energy and purpose.
"The Rare Gem"
Chocolate cake, banana filling, cream cheese buttercream layer, fresh banana slices.
Unique, layered, and one-of-a-kind.
"The Comforter"
Apple spice cake studded with tender apples, layered with brown butter cream cheese buttercream, and finished with a light drizzle of salted caramel.
Warm, grounded, and beautifully nurturing — a slice that feels like a cozy hug.
"The Gentle Heart"
Red velvet cake, whipped cream cheese buttercream.
Soft, sweet, and absolutely timeless.
"The Trailblazer"
Carrot cake, brown butter cream cheese buttercream.
Spiced, bold, and full of wisdom.
"The Powerhouse"
Strawberry cake, cheesecake filling, graham cracker crumble, strawberry compote, cream cheese buttercream, strawberry Swiss meringue buttercream.
Bold, powerhouse, and deeply rooted.
"The Prayerful Heart"
Brown sugar cake, Biscoff cookie butter filling, Biscoff buttercream, and layers of Biscoff cookie crumbs.
Grounded, inspiring, and nurturing — a slice of sweetness that lifts the spirit.
"The Prophetess"
Chai-spiced cake, pear filling, cream cheese buttercream.
Bold, layered, and full of fire — a warm, complex cake that speaks with vision and depth.
Ready to order?
Fill out the inquiry form and we'll get back to you within 24–48 hours with a formal quote.
Slots are limited — inquire early to secure your date.
Your slot is not confirmed until we respond and a deposit is received.